Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
rebellious_L

2009 Matthew Good (band) Elimination

Recommended Posts

Results from Round 1 E!

 

1) Generation X-Wing vs. Generation X-Wing (rooms) 10-13

2) In a World Called Catastrophe vs. Man of Action 3-20

3) Deep Six vs. The Vancouver National Anthem 3-20

4) The Boy Come Home vs. The Future Is X-Rated 9-14

5) Running For Home vs. My Life As a Circus Clown 21-2

6) Radio Bomb vs. The Devil's In Your Details 12-11 (thanks for that last vote steve, I almost had to give "Devil's" the win)

7) Giant vs. The Boy Who Could Explode 20-3

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure vs. 99% Of Us Is Failure (live acoustic) 23-0

9) Haven't Slept In Years (LOTGA) vs. Haven't Slept In Years (Raygun) 7-16 (was 7-7, then Raygun pulled away)

 

Round 1 F

 

1) Advertising on Police Cars vs. Advertising on Police Cars (rooms)

- Advertising on Police Cars defeated its rooms version in round 1 in 2005

- Advertising on Police Cars finished 5th overall in 2005

- MY VOTE - Advertising on Police Cars

 

2) A Long Way Down vs. Alert Status Red

- A Long Way Down lost to Fated in round 3 in 2005

- Alert Status Red lost in round 1 to Everything Is Automatic in 2005

- MY VOTE - Alert Status Red

 

3) Lone Gunman vs. Vermillion

- Lone Gunman did not exist in 2005

- Vermillion lost in round 1 to The Inescapable Us in 2005

- MY VOTE - Vermillion

 

4) The Rat Who Would Be King vs. She's Got a New Disguise

- The Rat Who Would Be King lost in round 3 to Suburbia in 2005

- She's Got a New Disguise finished 19th overall in 2005, lost in round 4 to Fated

- MY VOTE - The Rat Who Would Be King

 

5) The Inescapable Us vs. Empty's Theme Park

- The Inescapable Us lost in round 2 to Avalanche in 2005

- Empty's Theme Park did not exist in 2005

- MY VOTE - Empty's Theme Park

 

6) Rico vs. Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

- Rico lost to Symbolistic White Walls in round 2 in 2005

- Blue Skies Over Bad Lands lost in round 1 to Weapon in 2005, but was voted back on and finished 17th overall

- MY VOTE - Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

 

7) Annabelle vs. Lullaby For a New World Order

- Annabelle lost in round 1 to Ommissions of the Omen in 2005

- Lullaby For a New World Order lost in round 2 to 21st Century Living

- MY VOTE - Lullaby For a New World Order

 

8) Hello Time Bomb vs. Hello Time Bomb (rooms)

- Hello Time Bomb beat the rooms version in round 1 in 2005

- Hello Time Bomb lost in round 2 in 2005 to The Workers Sing a Song of Mass Production

- MY VOTE - Hello Time Bomb

 

9) North American For Life vs. North American For Life (rooms)

- North American For Life defeated the rooms version of itself in round 1 in 2005

- North American For Life lost in round 2 to All Together in 2005

- MY VOTE - North American For Life (but they're both just awful)

 

Voting for this round will end Saturday at midnight. Happy voting!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Advertising on Police Cars

2) A Long Way Down

3) Vermillion

4) The Rat Who Would Be King

5) Empty's Theme Park

6) Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

7) Annabelle (hard for me to choose but i've a soft spot for annabelle, not sure why, that and i think it won't get many votes)

8) Hello Time Bomb (the american version is the best)

9) North American For Life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Advertising on Police Cars

2) A Long Way Down

3) Vermillion

4) The Rat Who Would Be King

5) Empty's Theme Park

6) Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

7) Lulliby for a new world order

8) Hello Time Bomb (the american version is the best)

9) North American For Life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Advertising on Police Cars (AOB)

2) A Long Way Down

3) Lone Gunman (even though I can't understand all the words lol)

4) The Rat Who Would Be King (tough one)

5) Empty's Theme Park

6) Blue Skies Over Bad Lands (not a tough one, not a Rico hater but still, it doesn't have a chance IMHO)

7) Annabelle

8) Hello Time Bomb (BM)

9) North American For Life (WLRRR) (I personally really like this one, love the energy)

 

 

8) Hello Time Bomb (the american version is the best)

 

This is very true. The American BM may be inferior to the original but the remix of HTB on it is superior.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Advertising on Police Cars

 

2) Alert Status Red

 

3) Lone Gunman

 

4) She's Got a New Disguise

 

5) Empty's Theme Park (this one was not fair, they are so good. too early a match up!)

 

6) Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

 

7) Lullaby For a New World Order

 

8) Hello Time Bomb

 

9) North American For Life (I actually like this song)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Advertising on Police Cars

2) Alert Status Red

3) Vermillion

4) The Rat Who Would Be King

5) Empty's Theme Park

6) Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

7) Lullaby for a New World Order

8) Hello Time Bomb

9) North American For Life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9) North American For Life (I actually like this song)

 

Another one! High five!

 

"Yeah motherfucker we're number one"

Edited by Devil On Rollerskates

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We'll take what we wanna! Yeah we'll take what we wanna!

 

I never understood the hate for this song. It's a nice, fast-paced song.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Advertising on Police Cars

2. Alert Status Red

3. Lone Gunman

4. Rat Who WOuld be King

5. Empty's Theme Park

6. Blue Skies Over Badlands

7. Lullaby for a New World Order

8. Hello Time Bomb

9. North American for Life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
We'll take what we wanna! Yeah we'll take what we wanna!

 

I never understood the hate for this song. It's a nice, fast-paced song.

 

It's funny, people used to mock me for liking this song when I used to like it, but now that I've converted to their view people tell me it's a good song. Oh well, it was actually one of my favourites off of this album when it was first released, and then I put the album away for 2 years and since I've started listening to it again I haven't liked it at all. I've always enjoyed the blatant narcistic lyrics though

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Advertising on Police Cars

A Long Way Down

Vermillion

The Rat Who Would be King

The Inescapable Us

Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

Annabelle

Hello Time Bomb

North American For Life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) album

2) alert status red

3) vermillion

4) the rat

5) the inescapable us

6) rico (waiting for beating to happen)

7) anabelle

8) original one

9) original one

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Advertising on Police Cars

2) A Long Way Down

3) Vermillion

4) The Rat Who Would Be King (wins easily but SGAND is a sweet song either way)

5) Empty's Theme Park

6) Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

7) Lullaby For a New World Order

8) Hello Time Bomb (rooms)

9) North American For Life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've heard a lot of negative talk about North American For Life in the past on here as well, and always really liked that song. I think every time I listened to that song I would wonder how so many big fans didn't appreciate how good it is. It's a perfect example of typical sarcastic writing from MG combined with a killer beat and sound. Same type of song as Everything is Automatic in my mind. Glad to see people talking good about it. I'm not the only one!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Advertising on Police Cars

2) Alert Status Red

3) Vermillion

4) The Rat Who Would Be King

5) Empty's Theme Park

6) Rico

7) Lullaby For a New World Order

8) Hello Time Bomb

9) North American For Life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

round 1 F

 

1) Advertising on Police Cars

2) A Long Way Down

3) Vermillion

4) The Rat Who Would Be King

5) The Inescapable Us

6) Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

7) Annabelle

8) Hello Time Bomb

9) North American For Life

 

ps. number 8 was an easy one, hello time bomb from rooms is my least favourite MG(B) song of all time. And as i look to see who agrees i think there is only one vote for htb rooms version. I surely hope its life in this competition is short lived

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) AoPC

2) Long Way Down

3) Vermillion(probably the only time I'll vote for anything off Lotga in this thing)

4) The Rat

5) Empty's

6) Blue Skies

7) Lullaby

8) HTB

9) Rooms

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Advertising on Police Cars

2. Alert Status Red

3. Lone Gunman

4. Rat Who Would be King

5. Empty's Theme Park

6. Blue Skies Over Badlands

7. Lullaby for a New World Order

8. Hello Time Bomb

9. North American for Life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. album version

2. alert status red

3. vermilion (i dont know lone gunman but i really love vermilion)

4. rat who would be king

5. inescapable us

6. blue skies

7. annabelle

8. album version

9. album version

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Advertising on Police Cars

 

2) A Long Way Down

 

3) I've never even heard of The Lone Gunman so I'll withdraw my vote for now. If someone could send me the song, that'd be great.

 

4) The Rat Who Would Be King

 

5) Empty's Theme Park

 

6) Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

 

7) Lullaby for the New World Order

 

8) Hello Time Bomb

 

9) North American For Life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Advertising on Police Cars

Alert Status Red

The Lone Gunman

The Rat Who Would Be King

Empty's Theme Park

Blue Skies Over Bad Lands

Lullaby For The New World Order

Hello Time Bomb

North American For Life (easy win of the elimination) (I HATE the Rooms version)

 

1) original

2) Long

3) Vermillion

4) Disguise

5) Us

6) Bad

7) Order

8) Original

9) NAFL rooms

OHHH!!! *Slaps you with the RETARD stick!!!!* Not really that serious but I can't imagine how anyone could pick the Rooms version over the original. Not that the original is that great but the Rooms version is just so DREADFULLY, painfully almost, BLAND, DULL and BORRRRRING. Sorry but I felt compelled to say something about this unbelievably atrocious choice. Easily one of the worst things Matt's done. Still just an opinion though.

Edited by Manchalivin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Not that the original is that great but the Rooms version is just so DREADFULLY, painfully almost, BLAND, DULL and BORRRRRING. Sorry but I felt compelled to say something about this unbelievably atrocious choice. Easily one of the worst things Matt's done. Still just an opinion though.

;)

 

Ya I agree with you there, I honestly haven't listened to this song since the second time I listened to rooms the day after I bought it. Your post was so angry it inspired me to do so and I couldn't even get halfway through, just couldn't stand it. The lyrics to this song lose all their meaning when slowed down like that, it just doesn't work at all IMO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

long way down vs. alert status red decision will be interesting

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.