Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
rebellious_L

2009 Matthew Good (band) Elimination

Recommended Posts

Results From Round 1 F!

 

1) Advertising on Police Cars vs. Advertising on Police Cars (rooms) 20-1

2) A Long Way Down vs. Alert Status Red 11-10

3) Lone Gunman vs. Vermillion 5-15*

4) The Rat Who Would Be King vs. She's Got a New Disguise 17-4

5) The Inescapable Us vs. Empty's Theme Park 5-16

6) Rico vs. Blue Skies Over Bad Lands 3-18

7) Annabelle vs. Lullaby For a New World Order 8-13 (wow, can't believe Annabelle got that many votes)

8) Hello Time Bomb vs. Hello Time Bomb (rooms) 20-1

9) North American For Life vs. North American For Life (rooms) 18-3

 

*denotes abstention

 

Round 1 G

 

1) Champions of Nothing vs. Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

- this song did not exist in either format in 2005

- MY VOTE - Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

 

2) Let's Get It On vs. Can't Get Shot In the Back (If You Don't Run)

- Let's Get It On lost in round 2 to Load Me Up in 2005

- Can't Get Shot In The Back (If You Don't Run) lost in round 1 to In a World Called Catastrophe in 2005

- MY VOTE - Let's Get It On (really underrated in my opinion)

 

3) Change of Season vs. Song For the Girl

- lost in round 2 to Tripoli (rooms) in 2005

- Song For the Girl lost in Round 1 to Going All the Way in 2005

- MY VOTE - Change of Season

 

4) Bright End of Nowhere vs. Fated

- Bright End of Nowhere lost to The Rat Who Would Be King in round 2 in 2005

- Fated finished 10th overall in 2005, losing in round 5 to Advertising on Police Cars

- MY VOTE - Bright End of Nowhere (Fated = grossly overrated, Bright End of Nowhere = underrated)

 

5) Flight Recorder From Viking 7 vs. In Love With a Bad Idea

- Flight Recorder From Viking 7 lost to Near Fantastica in round 2 in 2005

- In Love With a Bad Idea lost to Avalanche in round 1 in 2005

- MY VOTE - Flight Recorder From Viking 7

 

6) It's Been Awhile Since I Was Your Man vs. I Wish I Was a Tidal Wave

- It's Been Awhile Since I Was Your Man lost in round 3 to Running For Home in 2005

- I Wish I Was a Tidal Wave did not exist in 2005 (if you don't have it, it's available in the NF Store)

- MY VOTE - hmmmm, not sure about this one, I'll go with It's Been Awhile

7) Invasion 1 vs. I'm a Window

- Invasion 1 lost to Change of Season in round 1 in 2005

- I'm a Window did not exist in 2005

- MY VOTE - I'm a Window

 

8) Avalanche vs. Avalanche (Massey Hall)

- Avalanche was voted champion in 2005

- Massey Hall recording did not exist in 2005

- MY VOTE - Massey Hall is awesome but you can't touch the classic, so Avalanche it is

 

9) Prime Time Deliverance vs. Prime Time Deliverance (rooms)

- Prime Time Deliverance finished third in 2005, losing to While We Were Hunting Rabbits in the semi-finals

- Prime Time Deliverance (rooms) lost in round 1 to Prime Time Deliverance in 2005

- MY VOTE - Prime Time Deliverance

 

Voting ends Wednesday at noon. Happy voting!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Champions of Nothing

2. Let's Get it On (agree, underrated)

3. Change of Season

4. Bright End of Nowhere (another underrated one)

5. Flight Recorder From Viking 7

6. It's Been Awhile Since I Was Your Man

7. Invasion 1

8. Avalanche

9. Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

Let's Get It On

Change of Season (hmm, for some reason I smell smoke show)

Bright End of Nowhere (tough decision)

Flight Recorder From Viking 7

It's Been A While Since I Was Your Man

Invasion 1

Avalanche

Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Champions (Massey)

Let's Get It On

Change

Bright End

Flight

Tidal Wave

Window

Avalanche (Massey)

PTD (Rooms)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

2) Let's Get It On

3) Change of Season

4) Bright End of Nowhere

--- Bright End was awesome live, loved it, and if Fated was just matt solo acoustic, like Edmonton boot or Massey Hall, it would probably win.

5) Flight Recorder From Viking 7

6) If I Was a Tidal Wave

--- dont' know why, just like this song a lot.

7) Invasion 1

8) Avalanche

9) Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

2) Let's Get It On

3) Change of Season

4) Bright End of Nowhere

5) Flight Recorder From Viking 7

6) It's Been Awhile Since I Was Your Man (i think it's actually "If I Was a Tidal Wave")

7) I'm a Window

8) Avalanche

9) Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

Let's Get It On

Change of Season

Fated

Flight Recorder From Viking 7

I Wish I Was a Tidal Wave

I'm a Window

Avalanche

Prime Time Deliverance (rooms)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

2) Let's Get It On (I agree, underrated)

3) Change of Season

4) Fated (though I agree Bright End Of Nowhere is underrated, I still like Fated more)

5) Flight Recorder From Viking 7

6) It's Been Awhile Since I Was Your Man

7) Invasion 1 (tough one)

8) Avalanche (Massey Hall) (tough one, though the original album version is awesomely fantastically great, this song is killer in any live version)

9) Prime Time Deliverance (Underdogs)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Massey Hall (love the last 2 minutes of that version)

2. Let's Get It On

3. Change of Season

4. Fated

5. Viking 7

6. It's Been Awhile Since I Was Your Man (I was so happy when he played it at my first Matt Good show last year)

7. I'm a Window (toughest one yet for me I think, love both these songs)

8. Massey Hall (both versions are great though)

9. Album (would be in my top 5 Matt Good songs, both versions are also great)

 

Also, I'm not at all suprised Annabelle got so many votes in the last round, it's a excellent song.

Edited by Curtster

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

2) Let's Get It On

3) Change of Season

4) Bright End of Nowhere

5) Flight Recorder From Viking 7

6) If I Was a Tidal Wave

7) I'm a Window

8) Avalanche

9) Prime Time Deliverance (rooms)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. champions of nothing (massey)

2. let's get it on

3. change of season

4. bright end of nowhere

5. flight recorder

6. its been a while

7. invasion 1 (grossly underrated)

8. avalanche (album)

9. prime time deliverance (album)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't believe Lullaby got that many votes. I don't really like that song.

 

Champions (Massey)

Let's Get it On

Change of Season

Fated

Flight Recorder

If I Was A Tidal Wave

I'm a Window

Avalanche (Massey)

Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I originally typed it as "If I Was a Tidal Wave" also but it was listed as "I Wish..." in my iTunes and upon looking at the version up in the nf store it also refers to it as "I Wish..." (which makes sense since I originally downloaded it from there) so I changed it. Now, looking in the lyrics section I see that there it is listed as "If I.." w/e.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Live

2) Shot In The Back

3) change of season

4) nowhere

5) bad idea

6) man

7) window

8) album

9) original

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Massey Hall

2) Can't Get Shot..

3) Change of Season

4) Bright End of Nowhere

5) Flight Recorder

6) Tidal Wave

7) Invasion 1

8) Massey

9) PTD

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Champions of Nothing

 

2) Can't Get Shot In The Back

 

3) Change of Season

 

4) Bright End of Nowhere

 

5) Flight Recorder From Viking 7

 

6) If I Was A Tidal Wave

 

7) I'm A Window

 

8) Avalanche

 

9) Prime Time Deliverance (Rooms)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Champions of Nothing

Let's Get It On

Change of Season

Fated

Flight Recorder From Viking 7

It's Been Awhile Since I Was Your Man

Invasion 1

Avalanche

Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Come on people, only 16 votes so far! Have your say or you'll be complaining when it's all over that someone decided that... RICO was declared the greatest Matt Good song ever! (okay, that may be unlikely to happen, but my point stands)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

Let's Get It On

Change of Season

Fated

In Love With a Bad Idea

I Wish I Was a Tidal Wave

Invasion 1

Avalanche

Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Champions of Nothing

Can't Get Shot In the Back

Song For the Girl (both these songs suck)

Fated (tough one, love them both)

Flight Recorder From Viking 7

I Wish I Was a Tidal Wave

I'm a Window

Avalanche

Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Massey Hall

2. Let's Get it On

3. Change of Season

4. Fated

5. Flight Recorder

6. It's Been awhile Since I was Your Man

7. I'm a Window

8. Avalanche

9. Rooms

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Massey Version

2. Let's Get it On

3. Change of Season

4. Fated

5. Bad Idea

6. Tidal Wave

7. I'm a Window

8. Avalanche

9. Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

well, after 20 votes there is at least one tie here, wonder if anyone will break it before noon!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

good morning,

 

1. Massey Hall

2. Let's Get It On

3. Change of Season

4. Bright End of Nowhere

5. Flight Recorder From Viking 7 (joke of a match)

6. If I Was a Tidal Wave (don't like either one)

7. I'm a Window

8. Avalanche

9. Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Champions of Nothing (Massey Hall)

Can't Get Shot In the Back (If You Don't Run)

Change of Season

Fated

Flight Recorder From Viking 7

abstain, haven't heard tidal wave

I'm a Window

Avalanche (Massey Hall)

Prime Time Deliverance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.