Jump to content
rebellious_L

2009 Matthew Good (band) Elimination

Recommended Posts

Round 2 AB results! (The blowout round)

 

1)House of Smoke and Mirrors vs. Symbolistic White Walls 14-9

2)The Fine Art of Falling Apart vs. My Out of Style is Coming Back 20-3

3)Suburbia vs. Jenni's Song 20-3

4)Near Fantastica vs. Double Life 22-1

5)Flashdance II vs. The War is Over 20-3

6)Put Out Your Lights vs. Weapon 0-23

7)Fought To Fight It vs. Tripoli 0-23

8)On Nights Like Tonight vs. Indestructible 16-7

9)Born Losers vs. I Am Not Safer Than a Bank 23-0

 

Three shutouts must be some kind of record, almost had four until Double Life got a vote near the end.

 

Round 2 CD

 

1) Empty Road vs. The Fall of Man

- Empty Road beat So Long Mrs. Smith 23-2

- The Fall of Man knocked out Everything is Automatic 12-10

- MY VOTE - The Fall of Man

 

2) I Miss New Wave vs. Volcanoes

- I Miss New Wave beat Breath of a Nation 20-2

- Volcanoes beat Little Terror 16-9

- MY VOTE - Volcanoes

 

3) Great Whales of the Sea vs. Alabama Motel Room

- Great Whales of the Sea defeated Moon Over Marin 22-3

- Alabama Motel Room beat Bad Pennies 15-6

- MY VOTE - Great Whales of the Sea

 

4) A Silent Army In the Trees vs. Black Helicopter (Massey Hall)

- A Silent Army In the Trees defeated its acoustic self 22-3

- Black Helicopter (Massey Hall) beat out the album version and acoustic version in a three way battle with 15 out of 21 voting it in first place

- MY VOTE - Black Helicopter (Massey Hall) (tough choice, if it was album Black Helicopter Silent Army would have my vote for sure)

 

5) Last Parade vs. Going All the Way

- Last Parade beat Buffalo Seven 21-4

- Going All the Way defeated Oh Be Joyful 18-7

- MY VOTE - Last Parade

 

6) Sort of a Protest Song vs. 21st Century Living

- Sort of a Protest Song defeated Under the Influence 21-4

- 21st Century Living knocked out I, the Throw Away 16-6

- MY VOTE - I'll miss you 21st Century Living, but Sort of a Protest Song has to be my choice

 

7) We're So Heavy vs. Anti-pop

- We're So Heavy defeated Strangest One of All 18-4

- Anti-pop knocked out Native Son 16-6

- MY VOTE - We're So Heavy

 

8) Single Explosion vs. Load Me Up

- Single Explosion beat She's In It For the Money 18-4

- Load Me Up defeated Middle Class Gangsters 19-6

- MY VOTE - Single Explosion

 

9) While We Were Hunting Rabbits vs. Truffle Pigs

- While We Were Hunting Rabbits defeated All Together 20-5

- Truffle Pigs beat Truffle Pigs (rooms) 17-5

- MY VOTE - I'm gonna take the underdog Truffle Pigs

 

Hopefully this round is a little tougher, it was for me anyways. Voting for this round will end Wednesday @ noon. Happy voting!

Edited by rebellious_L
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Empty Road

2. I Miss New Wave

3. Great Whales

4. A Silent Army

5. Last Parade

6. SOAPS

7. Anti Pop

8. A Single Explosion

9. WWWHR

 

Few tough ones in there. Especially 2 because I'm not crazy about either. I can't believe 21 Century beat I, The Throw Away last round. That's nuts. 21st is basically a meandering rant on record lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1) The Fall of Man

2) Volcanoes (toughest one yet)

3) Great Whales of the Sea

4) Black Helicopter (Massey Hall)

5) Last Parade

6) Sort of a Protest Song

7) We're So Heavy

8) Single Explosion

9) Truffle Pigs (next toughest)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lots of tough ones in there for me...

 

Empty Road

Volcanoes

Great Whales of the Sea

Silent Army in the Trees

Last Parade

Sort of a Protest Song

We're so Heavy

Single Explosion

Truffle Pigs

 

Last two both could have gone either way for me, all amazing songs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1) Empty Road vs. The Fall of Man

the fall of man

 

2) I Miss New Wave vs. Volcanoes

I miss new wave

 

3) Great Whales of the Sea vs. Alabama Motel Room

Great Whales of the Sea

 

4) A Silent Army In the Trees vs. Black Helicopter (Massey Hall)

- A Silent Army In the Trees

 

5) Last Parade vs. Going All the Way

- Last Parade

 

6) Sort of a Protest Song vs. 21st Century Living

21st Century Living

 

7) We're So Heavy vs. Anti-pop

Anti-pop

 

8) Single Explosion vs. Load Me Up

Load Me Up

 

9) While We Were Hunting Rabbits vs. Truffle Pigs

that ones tough, but i have to go with

Truffle Pigs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1) The Fall of Man (tough one)

2) I Miss New Wave (definitely toughest one so far, both fantastic)

3) Great Whales of the Sea

4) A Silent Army In the Trees

5) Last Parade

6) Sort of a Protest Song

7) We're So Heavy

8) Single Explosion

9) While We Were Hunting Rabbits

 

Few tough ones in there. Especially 2 because I'm not crazy about either.

 

Tough for me, too, but for the complete opposite reason.

Edited by Devil On Rollerskates
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Fall Of Man

I Miss New Wave

Great Whales of the Sea

Black Helicopter (Massey Hall)

Going All The Way

Sort of a Protest Song

We're So Heavy

Load Me Up (tough one)

While We Were Hunting Rabbits (Truffle Pigs is awesome though)

 

This round was tougher but still pretty easy overall.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1) The Fall of Man

 

2) I Miss New Wave (but if it was Volcanoes live...)

 

3) Great Whales of the Sea

 

4) A Silent Army In the Trees

 

5) Last Parade

 

6) Sort of a Protest Song

 

7) Anti-pop

 

8) Single Explosion

 

9) Truffle Pigs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.