Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
rebellious_L

2009 Matthew Good (band) Elimination

Recommended Posts

Round 2 GH results...

 

Since there was some technical issues on Sunday and some users were complaining about missing posts I won't post results until the end of this round which will be on the morning of Monday December 21st. A few votes were close and I'd like to make sure everyone's votes are counted. If you wanted to add a vote for that round, please just add it into this thread as the other one will likely be locked. The vote back for round 2 (round 2.5) will be held later as we cannot start it until the outcome of the last round is finalized.

 

Round 3 Group A

 

1) Near Fantastica vs. The Fall of Man

Near Fantastica defeated:

- Near Fantastica (HOSAM) 17-2

- Double Life 21-1

The Fall of Man defeated:

- Everything is Automatic 12-10

- Empty Road 15-9

- MY VOTE - Near Fantastica

 

2) Born Losers vs. We're So Heavy

Born Losers defeated:

- Raygun 13-4

- I Am Not Safer Than a Bank 22-0

We're So Heavy defeated:

- Strangest One of All 18-4

- Anti-Pop 14-10

- MY VOTE - We're So Heavy

 

3) The Fine Art of Falling Apart vs. I Miss New Wave

The Fine Art of Falling Apart defeated

- Carmelina 18-1

- My Out of Style is Coming Back 19-3

I Miss New Wave defeated

- Breath of a Nation 20-2

- Volcanoes 12-12

- MY VOTE - The Fine Art of Falling Apart (pretty close, but I'm still angry Volcanoes lost in such horrible fashion)

 

4) Flashdance II vs. While We Were Hunting Rabbits

Flashdance II defeated:

- Comfortable Criminals 15-2

- The War is Over 20-2

While We Were Hunting Rabbits defeated:

- All Together 20-5

- Truffle Pigs 15-9

- MY VOTE - I hate voting against Flashdance II, but I have to vote for Rabbits

 

5) Suburbia vs. On Nights Like Tonight

Suburbia defeated:

- Agoraphobe 17-2

- Jenni's Song 19-3

On Nights Like Tonight defeated:

- Look Happy, It's the End of the World 13-4

- Indestructible 16-6

- MY VOTE - Suburbia (love Nights though)

 

6) Sort of Protest Song vs. Last Parade

Sort of a Protest Song defeated:

- Under the Influence 21-4

- 21st Century Living 21-3

Last Parade defeated:

- Buffalo Seven 21-4

- Going All the Way 15-9

- MY VOTE - Sort of a Protest Song

 

Voting for this round will end the morning of Monday December 21st. Happy voting!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Near Fantastica

2) We're So Heavy

3) I Miss New Wave

4) While We Were Hunting Rabbits

5) Suburbia

6) Sort of a Protest Song

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Near Fantastica vs. The Fall of Man

Near Fantastica

 

Born Losers vs. We're So Heavy

Born Losers

 

The Fine Art of Falling Apart vs. I Miss New Wave

I Miss New Wave (always I Miss New Wave for me)

 

Flashdance II vs. While We Were Hunting Rabbits

While we were hunting rabbits

 

Suburbia vs. On Nights Like Tonight

Suburbia

 

Sort of Protest Song vs. Last Parade

last parade

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Near Fantastica

We're so Heavy

The Fine Art of Falling Apart

Flashdance II

Suburbia

Sort of Protest Song

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Near Fantastica

2. Born Losers

3. The Fine Art

4. Rabbits

5. Suburbia

6. SOAPS

 

A few questions... what is Near Fantastic (HOSAM)? Is that just the acoustic version with the additional lyrics? Also, look at the track 5 matchup and look how they got to this point? I don't understand how each song has a fair shot... like Nights was against 2 Underdog tracks and Suburbia (one of his best) was against Jenni's Song and one I've never heard of... Which leads me to my last question? What is the song Agoraphobe from?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
A few questions... what is Near Fantastic (HOSAM)? Is that just the acoustic version with the additional lyrics?

yes

 

Also, look at the track 5 matchup and look how they got to this point? I don't understand how each song has a fair shot... like Nights was against 2 Underdog tracks and Suburbia (one of his best) was against Jenni's Song and one I've never heard of...

Round 1 was selected randomly and this ultimately determines much of what happens before we even begin voting. Unless we rank all 147 songs involved beforehand this is really the only logical way to approach this. That is also why have a vote back after every round so that songs such as Failing the Rorschach Test, which I'm sure many would agree was unfairly matched against Weapon in round 1, still has a chance to earn a top 20 ranking and could even win it all.

 

Which leads me to my last question? What is the song Agoraphobe from?

check the NF store under +jackpillowhead. It was a demo Matt recorded with Ryan Dahle.

Edited by rebellious_L

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Near Fantastica

2) We're So Heavy

3) The Fine Art of Falling Apart

4) While We Were Hunting Rabbits

5) Suburbia

6) Sort of Protest Song

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Near

Born

I Miss

WWWHR

Sub

SOAP

 

I am glad volcanoes lost. One of the most boring, dull songs Matt has ever done (besides Rico)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Near Fantastica

2) Born Losers

3) The Fine Art of Falling Apart

4) While We Were Hunting Rabbits

5) Suburbia

6) Sort of Protest Song

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Near Fantastica

Born Losers

I Miss New Wave

While We Were Hunting Rabbits

Suburbia

Sort of Protest Song

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Near Fantastica

 

2) Born Losers

 

3) The Fine Art of Falling Apart

 

4) While We Were Hunting Rabbits

 

5) Suburbia

 

6) Sort of Protest Song

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Near Fantastica

2) Were So Heavy

3) The Fine Art of Falling Apart

4) While We Were Hunting Rabbits

5) Suburbia

6) Sort of a Protest Song

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Near Fantastica

2) Born Losers

3) I Miss New Wave

4) While We Were Hunting Rabbits

5) Suburbia

6) Last Parade

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. The Fall of Man

2. Born Losers

3. I Miss New Wave

4. While we were Hunting Rabbits

5. Suburbia

6. Sort of a Protest song

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Near Fantastica

We're So Heavy

The Fine Art of Falling Apart

While We Were Hunting Rabbits

On Nights Like Tonight

Last Parade

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Near Fantastica

2. Born Losers

3. Fine Art

4. Rabbits

5. Suburbia

6. SOAPS

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Fall of Man

We're So Heavy

The Fine Art of Falling Apart

While We Were Hunting Rabbits

Suburbia

Sort of a Protest Song

 

 

Another thing re: Agoraphobe- Ryan Dahle would re-record it for his solo album "Irrational Anthems".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Near Fantastica

2) We're So Heavy

3) I Miss New Wave (really tough)

4) While We Were Hunting Rabbits

5) Suburbia (tough one)

6) Last Parade

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Near Fantastica

Born Losers (they're pretty close)

I Miss New Wave

While We Were Hunting Rabbits

Suburbia

Last Parade

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Near Fantastica

Born Losers

The Fine Art Of Falling Apart

While We Were hunting Rabbits

Suburbia

Last Parade

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.