Which Pop/punk Band Sucks More?

[Berserkgatsu]

If you like any of these bands you should be stabbed in the face and kicked in the shins.

[savepenguins]

Its a tie between Good Charlotte and Simple Plan.

They are equally annoying and have the most meaningless lyrics imaginable.

Until I heard Simple Plan's newest single (I think its still their newset,) on the radio, I didnt think that any song was able to suck so much. It doesnt flow, its unoriginal, and if I really wanted to hear a song about someone's horrible life, I would go to a much more credible source.

[borntohula]

i think you should have added jersey to that list.

 

they all kind of suck.

 

however, blink have been able to remove themselves from that fake punk rock/juvenile kind of attitude with their latest album.

[habsfan6969]

I not ever say that I like Yellowcard, but I do think they are better than the other 3.

[no yu begin wher i end]

Good Charlotte. For me they come off a lot more fake than the others for some reason.

[cavalier_eternal]

simple plan is by far the worst. cookie cutter, whiny little north american pampered media whores. 'conform, kids! it makes you happy!'

 

i think blink redeemed themselves somewhat with the latest album. note how i say somewhat.

 

order of suckage (most to least)

 

simple plan

good charlotte

yellowcard

blink 182

[HoboFactory]

Yellowcard...

[Crusader]

Good Charlotte

[jhark]

That band who sings the song about the mom stuck in 1985 is waaay worse then all these bands

[Kumquat]

That'd be Bowling for Soup. That song is damn fun to dance in the car to, though.

 

Where's Sum 41? I hate them.

[pearanoid]

I heard the new Good Charlotte song the other night at a restaurant and at first I actually thought it was a new Jessica Simpson song or something, it has this stupid dance beat going on. Awful.

[Dan #2]

i had to vote simple plan.

 

sp> gc> yellowcard> blink

 

i actually love Blink, and Yellowcard are not bad at all, but holy shit, gc+sp are terrible.

[mikec]

I hate simple plan, so i voted for simple plan.

[savepenguins]

Doesnt that mean greater than?

The big side.. is greater than..

[Daedalus]

I had to vote blink 182. I have always hated them and my friends used to blast their crappy songs all the time. I have not listened to anything new by them as i tend to avoid all of these bands like the plague but Blink wins for tormenting me more in the past ;)

[Devil On Rollerskates]

I like that new Sum 41 song "We're All To Blame". Blink 182 isn't that bad either. SP, GC and Yellowcard are pretty annoying though.

[funkyjimjoe]

Good Charlotte has had my vote since their first album came out. Honestly, i can picture them getting up in the morning and putting black dye in they're hair, getting they're gothy/punkish make-up kits out and doing eachothers nails. The routine makes me sick. Nothing wrong with dressing like that, but these pretenders give anything they touch a bad name.

For just 20 dollars a year you can join they're "exclusive" fan club, definitly worth the special content. With songs like "Girls & Boys" or other ridiculously themed nonsense such as "emotionless" tearing away at my ear drums in shopping malls, clearly MG is right. Something is very wrong with the world.

Edited January 30, 2005 by funkyjimjoe

[CaptainRocket]

No question, Simple Plan. These guys are such phonies. They know their demographic is whiney thirteen year olds, whom 'no one understands', and they milk it. These guys should wipe my ass. Everyday. Until they die.

Good Charlotte is trying to milk the poseur goth look, and they sound pretty whiny too, but my secret shame is that I hum along to 'Predictable'...

Yellowcard should actually tie for worst with SP; I hate these guys.

I bought Dude Ranch in '97 (in Grade 7) and ever since, I have been a blink fan. I know they aren't that good, but I really like their last album. Bring on the hate if you will.

[Dan #2]

It's okay Captain Rocket, Predictable was decent... I thought that and the new single were decent, so i DLed the album... Holy shit, it was terrible!!!

[saturnine]

good charlotte before:

preppy 'punk' kids

 

good charlotte after:

whiny, angsty, fake goth wannabes

 

i can't imagine how tough it must be to be a rich, 30-something entrepeneur. their parents probably make them follow rules, or something.. oh, no!

[thefutureisxrated]

Blink 182 pre-dates all these bands by a few years. Like them or not, they have been around a while and have a distinct sound. It's not like they're the copycats.

 

Good Charlotte on the other hand is possibly the worst "band" I have heard in quite some time. It must really suck to be in your late twenties/early thirties and make music that only appeals to young high school kids. What a bunch of crap GC is.

Edited January 31, 2005 by thefutureisxrated

[Dan #2]

It must really suck to be in your late twenties/early thirties and make music that only appeals to young high school kids.

You're giving them too much credit. I can name like, four highschool kids at my school who like them. SimplePlan and GC are middle school.

[savepenguins]

Calling anyone fake is awful. They're probably just stupid kids who had problems at one point and are now trying to express themselves the best they can through music.

 

Try harder, bitches. You're getting paid to make this look real.

[Devil On Rollerskates]

I like one part of one Simple Plan song. The part where he says he's a dick.

[savepenguins]

That part sounds real.