Throw Away Vs. All Together

[rebellious_L]

Lots of people said they didn't like I, the throw away in the least fav song thread and many said all together was their fav b-side.

 

All Together all the way.

[andielicious]

i, the throw away is one of my favourite songs, so i'm inclined to say that one.

[deremac]

I realy like both songs so its a tough call but I would probly have to say All Together.

[Goudie]

im gonna have to go with I the throw away.

[Rebabaluba]

I really like I, the Throw Away, but All Together just seems to have another element that seems to work perfectly.

[saturnine]

all together

[timotheory]

I, The Throw Away has incredible lyrics. It also adds to the variety of AOB. So that's my pick.

[Brianj]

I throw away.

[c0micb0y]

i dunno, all together seems one of the weaker songs in the mg/b catalogue. It never sat right with me. it goes wrong for me in the vocal delivry near the end, too awkward ('and i been wonderi hi iin, what went wrong).

Dusk is a far better song, in the same vein

[Prometheon]

I despise Dusk, though I don't really know.

 

As for the poll, I said All Together. it just has this whole creepy vibe that's amazing.

[Computer]

I despise Dusk, though I don't really know.

 

As for the poll, I said All Together. it just has this whole creepy vibe that's amazing.

Agreed, its still a tough call, but I'd have to go with All Together.

[benneb]

I, The Throw Away

[shindig]

I, The Throw Away - fun to play on the guitar and sing too also

[Shiri]

I, The Throw Away

[i_the_throwaway]

I love both songs, but I voted for All Together. I think it's a better song, more heartfelt. However, the wording of this poll is a little odd - AT wouldn't have fit well on the album.

[glo]

All together for sure

[rebellious_L]

What a tight race. All Together's on the comeback trail!

[Shortcut To Moncton]

This is a great match but I gave it to I, The Throw Away because it's one of the most underappreciated songs on the AOB.

[cleric9999]

i, the throw away for sure

[scheurminator]

throw away will always be classic