Matthew Good [band] Elimination

[NationofCool]

Results From Group B

1) Omissions of the Omen 9 vs My Out of Style is Coming Back 16

2) Workers Sing a Song of Mass Production 10 vs Suburbia 15

3) Near Fantastica 10 vs Failing The Rorschach Test 15

 

NOTES:

- These were the closes tallied scores. Although there is a 5-7 point difference, these songs had to make a comeback of some sort or hold off a comeback attempt. Fun to tally that one!

 

ROUND 3: GROUP C MATCHUPS

1) Apparitions (36-3 --- Ranked #1) vs Alert Status Red (29-13 --- Ranked #21)

---“Apparitions” defeated:

Round 1: War is Over 19-1

Round 2: Jenni’s Song 17-2

---“Alert Status Red” defeated:

Round 1: Every Name is My Name 16-4

Round 2: Fearless 13-9

My Pick: I love Alert Status Red.. but how can you vote against Apparitions?

Prediction: Apparitions takes it easily. It’s the current #1 ranked song.. who dares to knock it out??

 

2) Advertising on Police Cars (33-10 --- Ranked #11) vs The Rat Who Would Be King (31-9 –Ranked #16)

---“Advertising on Police Cars” defeated:

Round 1:Let’s Get It On 14-7

Round 2: Under The Influence 19-3

---“The Rat Who Would Be King” defeated:

Round 1: Comfortable Criminals 17-6

Round 2: Flight Recorder From Viking VII 17-7

My Pick: Advertising on Police Cars.. oh lord.. AoPC RULES!

Prediction: This could be a close one.. going back to the coin toss.. AoPC = heads RWWBK = tails……….. Heads it is!

 

3) Weapon (36-9 -- Ranked #5) vs Tripoli (37-7 --- Ranked #4)

---“Weapon” defeated:

Round 1: Middle Class Gangsters 17-4

Round 2: I, The Throw Away 19-3

---“ Tripoli” defeated:

Round 1: Rico 16-4

Round 2: It’s Been a While Since I Was Your Man 21-3

My Pick: As much as it pains me to have to pick between the two.. I say Weapon.

Prediction: I think people like Tripoli more, again because it wasn’t a single. But look at their records.. almost identical! Should be a dooozie!

Edited October 9, 2004 by NationofCool

[Maverick]

lol, this one is a joke... and anyone who votes differently from myself needs some serious help:

 

1. Apparitions

2. AoPC

3. Weapon

 

Too easy this time..... There is no way Tripoli should be ranked 4th btw... hehe.

[Bladeso]

1. Alert Status Red

2. Advertising ong Police Cars

3. Tripoli

[mcgarnicle19]

Apparitions

Rat Who Would be King

Weapon

[NationofCool]

lol, this one is a joke... and anyone who votes differently from myself needs some serious help:

 

1. Apparitions

2. AoPC

3. Weapon

 

Too easy this time..... There is no way Tripoli should be ranked 4th btw... hehe.

I know this is the weakest of the 4 groups in round 3. It was originally group D, but when I noticed what the matchup in the other remaining group was.. I HAD to switch.. because there is a matchup that is of epic proportions!

[Hyphnip]

Apparitions

Rat Who Would be King

Tripoli

[VivaEllen]

1. Apparitions

2. AoPC

3. Weapon

[badseed]

1) Apparitions (not much of a contest, although ASR rules)

2) The Rat Who Would Be King (wow, really tough choice... I'm voting this because I know AoPC will win anyway)

3) Weapon (tough choice, for sure!)

 

Ahhh I'm getting so antsy.

[THE MAN]

1) Apparitions

2) Advertising on Police Cars

3) Weapon

[HoboFactory]

1. Alert Status Red

2. The Rat Who Would Be King

3. Tripoli

[no yu begin wher i end]

1) Apparitions

2) Advertising On Police Cars

3) Weapon

[Sparq]

1) Apparitions

2) Advertising on Police Cars

3) Weapon

[NationofCool]

you guys are borrrrriiing lol..

add some more comments.. so when i have to do a tally i have something fun to read ;)

[Crusader]

1) Apparitions

2) Advertising on Police Cars

3) Weapon

[Mouko]

1) Apparitions

2) Advertising On Police Cars

3) Weapon

 

Easy stuff.

[blue_soda025]

1. Apparitions (come on, now)

2. Advertising on Police Cars

3. Tripoli

[Mr.Domino]

Apparitions

Advertising on Police Cars

Tripoli

[thewickernightmare]

Apparitions

AoPC

Tripoli

[therethere]

1. Apparitions

2. Advertising On Police Cars

3. Weapon

[afterglow]

1. "Apparitions"

2. "Advertising on Police Cars"

3. "Weapon"

[Matt]

1) Apparitions

2) The Rat Who Would Be King

3) Tripoli

Edited October 10, 2004 by Matt

[lcpja]

1. Apparitions

2. Rat Who Would Be King

3. Weapon

[somethingrandom]

1) Apparitions

2) Advertising on Police Cars

3) Weapon

[Moonlight_Graham]

Apparitions (1st time a song came down to coin-flip. App. is a better video than a song, so i had to separate the 2)

Advertising on Police Cars (this was easy, the best track on AOB)

Tripoli (another toughy)

[Born to Kill]

1)Apparitions

2)Rat Who would be King

3)And I have to say....Weapon.

The last two were tough choices.